
Bobby McCanne
As a huge Tchaikovsky SF fan, this was both interesting and a bit of a let down. Plotted as an Odyssey, it didn't really connect with the subject matter, and some of the moral positions taken reflecting on society were a bit off, even if I mostly agree with the author. The conclusion wasn't particularly satisfying either, making this the first SF book of Tchaikovsky's I wouldn't immediately read again. A good book, but sadly not his best.

Simone
fave AI inspired fiction that ive read! the philosophical issues and the overall point of view are more accurate and intriguing than standard are-robots-conscious fare. reminds me of the xkcd comic getting at how other ppl think the idea of ai weaponry becoming self aware is scary, but what he finds terrifying is the idea of sophisticated Ai weaponry obeying humans. very satisfying ending.

David Stockman
This offbeat story of a dedicated yet errant valet robot is entertaining from beginning to end. In a dystopian future, he wanders through crumbling cities and manors for one purpose—to serve a master. The adventures he stumbles into, akin to Through the Looking Glass or The Wizard of OZ in humor and originality, conflict with his coded directives and are a delight to read. The author's descriptions, dialogue, and pacing are top-notch. Can't wait for the movie—CGI, of course.